\documentclass[8pt]{beamer}
\usepackage[ansinew]{inputenc}
\usepackage{amsmath,amssymb, xcolor}
\usepackage{graphicx}
\usepackage{pgf,tikz}
\usepackage{mathrsfs}
\usetikzlibrary{arrows}
\usepackage{beamerthemesplit}
%\usepackage[french]{babel}
\usepackage{blindtext}
\usepackage{hyperref}

\def\R{\mathbb{R}}
\def\Z{\mathbb{Z}}
\def\H{\mathbb{H}}
\def\eps{\epsilon}
\def\pcite#1{\textcolor{red}{(#1)}}
\def\ncite#1{\textcolor{red}{#1}}

\newtheorem{proposition}{Proposition}


\title{Horizontal filling in Heisenberg balls}
\date{June 18th, 2025}

\author{Pierre Pansu, Universit\'e Paris-Saclay}


\mode<presentation>{\usetheme{Warsaw}}

\begin{document}

\begin{frame}
\titlepage
\end{frame}

\begin{frame}

\frametitle{Filling in Euclidean space}

Joint work with Bruno Franchi.

\bigskip

\begin{theorem}[\ncite{F. Almgren (1986)}]
Every closed integral $k$-current $S$ in $\R^n$ bounds an integral $k+1$-current $T$ such that
\begin{align*}
M(T)\le c_k\,M(S)^{\frac{k+1}{k}},
\end{align*}
and equality holds for round spheres contained in $k+1$-dimensional linear subspaces.
\end{theorem}\pause

\medskip

\textbf{Sobolev}. When $k=n-1$, this is the classical isoperimetric inequality, equivalent to the $(\frac{n}{n-1},1)$-Sobolev inequality.\pause

\bigskip

\textbf{Geometric group theory}. The filling inequality with $k=1$ is a quasiisometry invariant of finitely generated groups, equivalent to the \emph{Dehn function} measuring the hardness of the word problem.

\end{frame}

\begin{frame}

\frametitle{Relative filling in Euclidean space}

\begin{minipage}{5cm}

\begin{center}
\definecolor{wwccqq}{rgb}{0.4,0.8,0.}
\definecolor{ffqqqq}{rgb}{1.,0.,0.}
\begin{tikzpicture}[line cap=round,line join=round,>=triangle 45,x=0.2cm,y=0.2cm]
\clip(0.25910028241317484,-13.82936764568562) rectangle (18.119082722714538,3.5701364259891526);
\fill[line width=0.pt,color=wwccqq,fill=wwccqq,fill opacity=0.1] (8.,0.) -- (8.153015173154099,-2.7778867986483347) -- (9.468667654944255,-5.57364832245241) -- (11.244798505360963,-7.415561796958624) -- (14.,-8.698322966704023) -- (15.356212510955194,-3.3370391034091496) -- (16.,1.399309831035401) -- (16.,2.) -- (6.541340882961162,2.) -- (6.6400148190954225,0.9059401503640937) -- cycle;
\fill[line width=0.pt,color=ffqqqq,fill=ffqqqq,fill opacity=0.1] (6.6400148190954225,0.9059401503640937) -- (6.921011514659387,-1.4900677343818225) -- (8.,-4.) -- (9.669286102906861,-6.128916067376436) -- (9.468667654944255,-5.57364832245241) -- (8.153015173154099,-2.7778867986483347) -- (8.,0.) -- cycle;
\draw [line width=1.6pt] (2.,0.)-- (2.,-12.);
\draw [line width=1.6pt] (2.,-12.)-- (14.,-12.);
\draw [line width=1.6pt] (14.,-12.)-- (14.,0.);
\draw [line width=1.6pt] (14.,0.)-- (2.,0.);
\draw [line width=1.2pt] (2.,0.)-- (4.,2.);
\draw [line width=1.2pt] (14.,0.)-- (16.,2.);
\draw [line width=1.2pt] (14.,-12.)-- (16.,-10.);
\draw [line width=1.2pt] (16.,-10.)-- (16.,2.);
\draw [line width=1.2pt] (16.,2.)-- (4.,2.);
\draw (4.,2.)-- (4.,-10.);
\draw (4.,-10.)-- (16.,-10.);
\draw (4.,-10.)-- (2.,-12.);
\draw [shift={(8.075345289914232,1.5868731519597943)},line width=2.pt,color=ffqqqq]  plot[domain=2.878521542626677:4.664944263569087,variable=\t]({1.*1.5886608552875832*cos(\t r)+0.*1.5886608552875832*sin(\t r)},{0.*1.5886608552875832*cos(\t r)+1.*1.5886608552875832*sin(\t r)});
\draw [shift={(15.975183367433726,-0.917339013794576)},line width=2.pt,color=ffqqqq]  plot[domain=3.027071751776823:4.4637924265911675,variable=\t]({1.*8.027768096452535*cos(\t r)+0.*8.027768096452535*sin(\t r)},{0.*8.027768096452535*cos(\t r)+1.*8.027768096452535*sin(\t r)});
\draw [shift={(-29.621046511308077,5.188415627414753)},line width=2.pt,color=ffqqqq]  plot[domain=5.974980261959869:6.200319411792087,variable=\t]({1.*45.77813023183768*cos(\t r)+0.*45.77813023183768*sin(\t r)},{0.*45.77813023183768*cos(\t r)+1.*45.77813023183768*sin(\t r)});
\draw [shift={(14.708861377737119,55.83850673225151)},line width=2.pt,color=ffqqqq]  plot[domain=4.561832880506739:4.73610161188985,variable=\t]({1.*54.45450576574243*cos(\t r)+0.*54.45450576574243*sin(\t r)},{0.*54.45450576574243*cos(\t r)+1.*54.45450576574243*sin(\t r)});
\draw [shift={(17.050436952274598,1.3775575972467997)},line width=2.pt,color=ffqqqq]  plot[domain=3.082432848528217:4.418414426350393,variable=\t]({1.*10.527513226721886*cos(\t r)+0.*10.527513226721886*sin(\t r)},{0.*10.527513226721886*cos(\t r)+1.*10.527513226721886*sin(\t r)});
\draw [line width=2.pt,color=wwccqq] (8.,0.)-- (14.,0.);
\draw [line width=2.pt,color=wwccqq] (14.,0.)-- (14.,-8.698322966704023);
\draw [line width=2.pt,color=wwccqq] (14.,0.)-- (16.,2.);
\draw [line width=2.pt,color=wwccqq] (16.,2.)-- (16.,1.399309831035401);
\draw [line width=2.pt,color=wwccqq] (16.,2.)-- (6.541340882961162,2.);
\draw [color=ffqqqq](6.870254003408705,-4.389561088841273) node[anchor=north west] {$S$};
\draw [color=wwccqq](16.408734496387332,0.2810052215137701) node[anchor=north west] {$\tilde S$};
\draw (1.8,-4.652691585199303) node[anchor=north west] {$V$};
\end{tikzpicture}
\end{center}

\end{minipage}\hskip0cm\begin{minipage}{5cm}

\textbf{Relative filling inequality} in manifold with boundary $V$:  \begin{itemize}
  \item input = current $S$ with $\partial S\subset\partial V$. 
  \item output = current $T$ such that $\partial T=S+\tilde S$ with $\tilde S\subset\partial V$.
\end{itemize}\pause


\vskip.7cm

The following follows from Federer-Fleming's Deformation Theorem (constants are not sharp).

\end{minipage}

\begin{theorem}[\ncite{H. Federer and W. Fleming (1960)}]%MR0123260
Let $V$ be a Euclidean cube of side $R$. For every integral $k$-current $S$ in $V$ with $\partial S$ supported in $\partial V$, there exists an integral $k+1$-current $T$ in $V$ and an integral $k$-current $\tilde S$ supported in $\partial V$ such that $\partial T=S+\tilde S$ and
\begin{align*}\label{relativeclassical}
M(T)\le c'_k R\,M(S),\quad M(\tilde S)\le c'_k \,M(S).
\end{align*}
\end{theorem}

\medskip

When $k=n-1$, this statement is (up to constants) equivalent to a $(1,1)$-Poincar\'e inequality.


\end{frame}

\begin{frame}

\frametitle{Absolute filling in Heisenberg groups}

The absolute filling inequality in Riemannian Heisenberg groups is known (conjectured by \ncite{M. Gromov (1992)}).%

\begin{theorem}[\ncite{R. Young (2013, 2016)}]%MR3134033,MR3472846 
In the Heisenberg group $\H^{2m+1}$ equipped with a left-invariant Riemannian metric, every Lipschitz $k$-cycle $\alpha$ bounds a Lipschitz $k+1$-chain $\beta$ such that
$$
M(\beta)\le C\,M(\alpha)^{\frac{d(k)+1}{d(k)}},
$$
where
$$
d(k)=\begin{cases}
k & \text{if }k\le m, \\
k+1 & \text{otherwise}.
\end{cases}
$$
\end{theorem} \pause

\medskip

The number $d(k)$ is the Hausdorff dimension of smooth $k$-dimensional submanifolds in subRiemannian $\H^{2m+1}$. This suggests looking for a subRiemannian formulation of R. Young's theorem.

\end{frame}

\begin{frame}

\frametitle{Horizontal currents}

In $\H^{2m+1}$, let $\theta$ denote a left-invariant contact form. %We use a left-invariant subRiemannian metric on the distribution $\mathrm{Ker}(\theta)$. 
Currents and masses are defined with respect to a left-invariant Riemannian metric.

\begin{definition}
In $\H^{2m+1}$, say an integral current $T$ is \emph{horizontal} if
$$
T\llcorner \theta =0 \quad \text{and}\quad \partial T\llcorner \theta=0.
$$
\end{definition}

For a test form $\phi$, $\langle T\llcorner \theta,\phi \rangle :=\langle T,\theta\wedge\phi \rangle$.
Horizontal integral currents exist only in dimensions $k\le m$.\pause

\medskip

Here is our reformulation of Young's theorem in dimensions $k\le m$.

\begin{proposition}
In $\H^{2m+1}$, for $1\le k\le m-1$, every compactly supported closed $k$-dimensional horizontal integral current $S$ bounds a $k+1$-dimensional horizontal integral current $T$ such that
$$
M(T)\le C\,M(S)^{\frac{k+1}{k}}.
$$
\end{proposition} 

\end{frame}

\begin{frame}

\frametitle{Relative filling in Heisenberg groups}

The relative filling inequality is new. 

\begin{theorem}
In $\H^{2m+1}$, let $V$ be a ball of radius $R$. Let $k\le m-1$, let $0<\lambda<\mu<1$. Let $k\le n-1$. For every horizontal integral $k$-current $S$ such that $\partial S$ is supported in the complement of $V$, there exists a horizontal integral $k$-current $\tilde S$ and a horizontal integral $k+1$-current $T$ such that 
\begin{enumerate}
  \item $\tilde S$ is supported in the complement of $\lambda V$ ;
  \item $\partial T-S-\tilde S$ is supported in the complement of $\mu V$ ;
  \item $M(T)\le \Phi(M(S))$, where
  $$
\Phi(t)=C\,\min\{t^{(k+1)/k},R\,t\};
  $$
  \item $M(\tilde S)\le C\,M(S)$, $M(\partial \tilde S)\le \frac{C}{R}\,M(S)$.
\end{enumerate}
\end{theorem} 

\begin{minipage}{5cm}
It is a bit weak since a loss on the domain is allowed.
\end{minipage}\begin{minipage}{5cm}

\begin{center}
\definecolor{ttttff}{rgb}{0.2,0.2,1.}
\definecolor{wwccqq}{rgb}{0.4,0.8,0.}
\definecolor{ffqqqq}{rgb}{1.,0.,0.}
\begin{tikzpicture}[line cap=round,line join=round,>=triangle 45,x=0.3cm,y=0.3cm]
\clip(-2.326254166488392,-8.680043116571117) rectangle (7.169076071341301,0.5146900746233595);
\fill[line width=0.pt,color=ttttff,fill=ttttff,fill opacity=0.1] (-1.4775095642242855,0.21409302798815544) -- (-0.9585364568127179,-1.2194041783762235) -- (-0.11309983633605647,-2.767706809863309) -- (0.7327628375051592,-3.888172549621688) -- (1.4381002382470056,-4.6315085999637375) -- (2.3218351482645243,-5.391337202541401) -- (3.1134305891204948,-5.946214992189191) -- (3.9947949199073314,-6.450325394612287) -- (4.797620854849744,-6.820045797326619) -- (5.537110435702572,-7.09342959047301) -- (6.320331469077195,-7.318515317105781) -- (5.7545017342344575,-5.6033439333637345) -- (5.5263087624773455,-4.08921585064877) -- (4.685601634674522,-2.3219241342257493) -- (4.198469963416929,-1.7132645063199174) -- (2.1698145528614696,-0.26742245664690323) -- (0.779757738669916,0.14136907036704915) -- (-0.47750956422428475,0.21409302798815544) -- cycle;
\draw [line width=1.6pt] (-2.,-8.)-- (6.,-8.);
\draw [line width=1.6pt] (6.,-8.)-- (6.,0.);
\draw [line width=1.6pt] (6.,0.)-- (-2.,0.);
\draw [line width=1.6pt] (-2.,0.)-- (-2.,-8.);
\draw (-1.,-7.)-- (5.,-7.);
\draw (5.,-7.)-- (5.,-1.);
\draw (5.,-1.)-- (-1.,-1.);
\draw (-1.,-1.)-- (-1.,-7.);
\draw (0.,-6.)-- (4.,-6.);
\draw (4.,-6.)-- (4.,-2.);
\draw (4.,-2.)-- (0.,-2.);
\draw (0.,-2.)-- (0.,-6.);
\draw [shift={(8.908770477386692,3.1635765326887664)},line width=2.pt,color=ffqqqq]  plot[domain=3.418287086857436:4.47029317142879,variable=\t]({1.*10.79695633256278*cos(\t r)+0.*10.79695633256278*sin(\t r)},{0.*10.79695633256278*cos(\t r)+1.*10.79695633256278*sin(\t r)});
\draw [shift={(-0.1903081186087899,-5.7250218068156205)},line width=2.pt,color=wwccqq]  plot[domain=0.020465059270445646:1.6191163033500964,variable=\t]({1.*5.946054968746078*cos(\t r)+0.*5.946054968746078*sin(\t r)},{0.*5.946054968746078*cos(\t r)+1.*5.946054968746078*sin(\t r)});
\draw [line width=2.pt,color=ttttff] (-1.4775095642242855,0.21409302798815544)-- (-0.47750956422428475,0.21409302798815544);
\draw [line width=2.pt,color=ttttff] (5.7545017342344575,-5.6033439333637345)-- (6.320331469077195,-7.318515317105781);
\draw [color=ffqqqq](0.6443519414359814,-4.666188435030452) node[anchor=north west] {$S$};
\draw [color=ttttff](2.,-2.526644750156352) node[anchor=north west] {$T$};
\draw [color=wwccqq](6.,-2.6327378254393654) node[anchor=north west] {$\tilde S$};
\end{tikzpicture}
\end{center}

\end{minipage}

\end{frame}

\begin{frame}

\frametitle{Proof of the absolute filling inequality}

Given a closed horizontal integral current $S$, 
\begin{enumerate}
  \item \emph{Inflate}. Let $S_t=\delta_t(S)$, $t$ large. Then $M(S_t)\sim t^k$.\pause
  \item \emph{Approximate}. Use the Deformation Theorem in Riemannian manifolds to approximate $S_t$ in flat norm with a Riemannian Lipschitz cycle $\alpha_t$, $M(\alpha_t)\sim t^k$, $F(S_t-\alpha_t)\le 1$. \pause
    \item \emph{Apply Young's theorem}. Get a Riemannian Lipschitz chain $\beta_t$ such that $\partial\beta_t=\alpha_t$, $M(\beta_t) \sim t^{k+1}$. \pause
    \item \emph{Deflate}. Let $T_t=\delta_{1/t}(\beta_t)$. Then $M(T_t)\sim 1$, $M(\partial T_t)\sim 1$ and $F(S-\partial T_t)\sim t^{-1}\to 0$. \pause
    \item \emph{Compactness}. In flat norm, $T_t$ subconverges to some integral current $T$. \pause
    \item \emph{Estimate}. For a horizontal test form $\phi$ of degree $k$,
\begin{align*}
|\langle T_t,\theta\wedge\phi \rangle|
&=|\langle \beta_t,\delta_{1/t}^*\theta\wedge\delta_{1/t}^*\phi \rangle|\\
&\le M(\beta_t)\,\|\delta_{1/t}^*\theta\|_\infty \, \|\delta_{1/t}^*\phi\|_\infty
\\
&\le t^{k+1}t^{-2}t^{-k}=t^{-1}\to 0,
\end{align*}
hence $T\llcorner\theta=0$, $\partial T=S$, $T$ is horizontal and fills $S$.
\end{enumerate}

\end{frame}

\begin{frame}

\frametitle{Federer-Fleming's proof of the Euclidean filling inequality}


\begin{minipage}{7cm}

Apply the Deformation Theorem with parameter $\eps$. Write
$$S=P(S)+\partial Q(S)+Q'(\partial S),$$
where $P(S)$ is a finite sum of cubes of an $\eps$-grid, 
$$M(P(S))< C\, M(S),\quad M(Q(S))< C\eps\, M(S)\quad\text{and}$$
$$M(Q(\partial S))< C\, M(\partial S).$$
If $\partial S=0$, $Q'(\partial S)=0$. Choosing $\eps$ such that $C \,M(S)=\eps^k$ implies $P(S)=0$, this provides a filling $Q(S)$ with 
$$M(Q(S))\le C\,C^{1/k}\,M(S)^{1/k}\, M(S).$$ 

\end{minipage}\hskip-.1cm\begin{minipage}{3cm}

\begin{center}
\definecolor{ttzzqq}{rgb}{0.2,0.6,0.}
\definecolor{qqqqff}{rgb}{0.,0.,1.}
\definecolor{ffqqqq}{rgb}{1.,0.,0.}
\definecolor{zzttqq}{rgb}{0.6,0.2,0.}
\begin{tikzpicture}[line cap=round,line join=round,>=triangle 45,x=0.4cm,y=0.4cm]
\clip(-1.888552373788748,-12.209087750270502) rectangle (8.395981164083201,-3.1176205112119204);
\fill[color=zzttqq,fill=zzttqq,fill opacity=0.1] (6.803147029375748,-4.) -- (4.,-4.) -- (4.,-8.) -- (4.695965427257001,-8.) -- (4.80470058360462,-7.113637506984076) -- (5.168661315267897,-6.366083307094751) -- (5.62316470182041,-5.62316470182041) -- (6.417605402759644,-4.9600773271010405) -- cycle;
\fill[color=zzttqq,fill=zzttqq,fill opacity=0.1] (4.695965427257001,-8.) -- (8.,-8.) -- (8.,-12.) -- (0.,-12.) -- (0.,-9.495604623460858) -- (1.2979917913962629,-9.822955152643875) -- (1.314604106949337,-10.23524262046158) -- (1.487136471890958,-10.512863528109042) -- (2.6686730353468873,-10.668673035346888) -- (4.,-10.80459198078136) -- (5.195408019218509,-10.804591980781492) -- (5.941308243544778,-10.709332548938692) -- (6.519352430834264,-10.519352430834264) -- (7.275110294280937,-10.170671912779817) -- (7.716386436911047,-9.626627787016314) -- (7.523544172448507,-9.402419612068915) -- (6.84046434411138,-9.098054110326865) -- (5.514499520873422,-8.681236010994665) -- (4.726169637353564,-8.373153068009902) -- cycle;
\draw [color=zzttqq] (0.,-4.)-- (0.,-12.);
\draw (4.,-4.)-- (4.,-12.);
\draw (8.,-4.)-- (8.,-12.);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (0.,-4.)-- (8.,-4.);
\draw (0.,-8.)-- (8.,-8.);
\draw (0.,-12.)-- (8.,-12.);
\draw [line width=2.8pt,color=ffqqqq] (1.2979917913962473,-9.822955152643829)-- (1.3130938964445174,-9.868261467788638)-- (1.3130938964445174,-9.943771993029989)-- (1.3130938964445174,-10.00418041322307)-- (1.2979917913962473,-10.049486728367878)-- (1.2979917913962473,-10.10989514856096)-- (1.2979917913962473,-10.17030356875404)-- (1.3130938964445174,-10.230711988947121)-- (1.3281960014927874,-10.276018304091929)-- (1.3432981065410574,-10.32132461923674)-- (1.3584002115893274,-10.36663093438155)-- (1.3886044216858677,-10.41193724952636)-- (1.403706526734138,-10.45724356467117)-- (1.4490128418789483,-10.48744777476771)-- (1.4943191570237584,-10.51765198486425)-- (1.5396254721685692,-10.532754089912522)-- (1.6000338923616495,-10.532754089912522)-- (1.6453402075064598,-10.562958300009061)-- (1.6906465226512704,-10.57806040505733)-- (1.7510549428443505,-10.57806040505733)-- (1.796361257989161,-10.5931625101056)-- (1.8567696781822414,-10.5931625101056)-- (1.917178098375322,-10.5931625101056)-- (1.9624844135201323,-10.608264615153871)-- (2.022892833713213,-10.608264615153871)-- (2.068199148858023,-10.62336672020214)-- (2.128607569051104,-10.62336672020214)-- (2.1890159892441843,-10.638468825250412)-- (2.2494244094372644,-10.638468825250412)-- (2.3098328296303445,-10.638468825250412)-- (2.3702412498234255,-10.638468825250412)-- (2.4155475649682354,-10.653570930298683)-- (2.4910580902095862,-10.668673035346952)-- (2.566568615450937,-10.668673035346952)-- (2.626977035644017,-10.668673035346952)-- (2.687385455837098,-10.668673035346952)-- (2.7477938760301783,-10.668673035346952)-- (2.823304401271529,-10.668673035346952)-- (2.8837128214646097,-10.668673035346952)-- (2.9441212416576903,-10.668673035346952)-- (3.0045296618507704,-10.668673035346952)-- (3.064938082043851,-10.668673035346952)-- (3.1102443971886613,-10.683775140395221)-- (3.1555507123334716,-10.698877245443493)-- (3.2159591325265517,-10.698877245443493)-- (3.291469657767903,-10.698877245443493)-- (3.3669801830092534,-10.729081455540031)-- (3.4273886032023335,-10.744183560588302)-- (3.487797023395414,-10.744183560588302)-- (3.5482054435884947,-10.744183560588302)-- (3.593511758733305,-10.759285665636572)-- (3.6539201789263855,-10.774387770684843)-- (3.7143285991194657,-10.774387770684843)-- (3.7747370193125462,-10.774387770684843)-- (3.850247544553897,-10.774387770684843)-- (3.8955538596987074,-10.804591980781382)-- (3.9559622798917875,-10.804591980781382)-- (4.0163707000848685,-10.804591980781382)-- (4.076779120277949,-10.804591980781382)-- (4.13718754047103,-10.804591980781382)-- (4.19759596066411,-10.804591980781382)-- (4.258004380857191,-10.804591980781382)-- (4.318412801050271,-10.804591980781382)-- (4.378821221243351,-10.804591980781382)-- (4.469433851532973,-10.804591980781382)-- (4.544944376774322,-10.804591980781382)-- (4.620454902015673,-10.804591980781382)-- (4.680863322208754,-10.804591980781382)-- (4.741271742401834,-10.804591980781382)-- (4.801680162594915,-10.804591980781382)-- (4.877190687836265,-10.804591980781382)-- (4.952701213077615,-10.804591980781382)-- (5.028211738318967,-10.804591980781382)-- (5.088620158512047,-10.804591980781382)-- (5.149028578705128,-10.804591980781382)-- (5.209436998898207,-10.804591980781382)-- (5.284947524139559,-10.804591980781382)-- (5.345355944332638,-10.804591980781382)-- (5.435968574622259,-10.804591980781382)-- (5.51147909986361,-10.804591980781382)-- (5.55678541500842,-10.789489875733112)-- (5.6322959402497705,-10.789489875733112)-- (5.753112780635932,-10.744183560588302)-- (5.813521200829013,-10.744183560588302)-- (5.873929621022093,-10.744183560588302)-- (5.934338041215174,-10.713979350491762)-- (5.979644356359984,-10.683775140395221)-- (6.024950671504794,-10.668673035346952)-- (6.085359091697875,-10.653570930298683)-- (6.145767511890955,-10.638468825250412)-- (6.1910738270357655,-10.62336672020214)-- (6.236380142180575,-10.608264615153871)-- (6.296788562373656,-10.5931625101056)-- (6.3571969825667365,-10.57806040505733)-- (6.417605402759817,-10.562958300009061)-- (6.5233201380977075,-10.51765198486425)-- (6.583728558290788,-10.51765198486425)-- (6.644136978483869,-10.472345669719441)-- (6.6894432936286785,-10.45724356467117)-- (6.734749608773489,-10.442141459622901)-- (6.795158028966569,-10.41193724952636)-- (6.85556644915965,-10.38173303942982)-- (6.931076974401001,-10.351528829333281)-- (6.9763832895458116,-10.33642672428501)-- (7.036791709738892,-10.291120409140198)-- (7.082098024883702,-10.276018304091929)-- (7.157608550125052,-10.24581409399539)-- (7.202914865269864,-10.21560988389885)-- (7.263323285462943,-10.18540567380231)-- (7.323731705656024,-10.10989514856096)-- (7.369038020800834,-10.079690938464418)-- (7.429446440993915,-10.00418041322307)-- (7.489854861186996,-9.943771993029989)-- (7.535161176331806,-9.898465677885179)-- (7.565365386428346,-9.853159362740369)-- (7.595569596524887,-9.80785304759556)-- (7.6408759116696965,-9.762546732450748)-- (7.7012843318627775,-9.702138312257668)-- (7.716386436911047,-9.641729892064587)-- (7.716386436911047,-9.581321471871508)-- (7.7012843318627775,-9.536015156726696)-- (7.655978016717967,-9.475606736533617)-- (7.610671701573156,-9.445402526437075)-- (7.565365386428346,-9.430300421388806)-- (7.474752756138725,-9.369892001195726)-- (7.384140125849105,-9.339687791099186)-- (7.323731705656024,-9.309483581002645)-- (7.263323285462943,-9.279279370906107)-- (7.218016970318133,-9.264177265857837)-- (7.172710655173324,-9.249075160809566)-- (7.112302234980242,-9.218870950713026)-- (7.066995919835433,-9.203768845664756)-- (7.021689604690622,-9.188666740616487)-- (6.9763832895458116,-9.158462530519945)-- (6.931076974401001,-9.128258320423404)-- (6.885770659256191,-9.113156215375135)-- (6.84046434411138,-9.098054110326865)-- (6.7800559239183,-9.098054110326865)-- (6.71964750372522,-9.067849900230325)-- (6.659239083532139,-9.067849900230325)-- (6.613932768387329,-9.052747795182055)-- (6.568626453242518,-9.037645690133784)-- (6.478013822952897,-9.007441480037244)-- (6.417605402759817,-8.977237269940705)-- (6.311890667421927,-8.977237269940705)-- (6.251482247228846,-8.931930954795895)-- (6.206175932084036,-8.916828849747624)-- (6.1306654068426845,-8.916828849747624)-- (6.055154881601334,-8.886624639651084)-- (5.979644356359984,-8.856420429554545)-- (5.889031726070363,-8.811114114409733)-- (5.783316990732472,-8.780909904313193)-- (5.722908570539392,-8.750705694216654)-- (5.647398045298041,-8.720501484120113)-- (5.586989625104961,-8.705399379071844)-- (5.54168330996015,-8.690297274023573)-- (5.49637699481534,-8.675195168975304)-- (5.420866469573989,-8.660093063927034)-- (5.375560154429179,-8.629888853830494)-- (5.330253839284368,-8.614786748782223)-- (5.224539103946477,-8.569480433637414)-- (5.164130683753397,-8.554378328589141)-- (5.118824368608586,-8.539276223540872)-- (5.0735180534637765,-8.509072013444332)-- (5.013109633270696,-8.478867803347793)-- (4.967803318125886,-8.463765698299522)-- (4.922497002981076,-8.448663593251252)-- (4.862088582787995,-8.418459383154712)-- (4.786578057546644,-8.40335727810644)-- (4.726169637353564,-8.373153068009902)-- (4.711067532305294,-8.327846752865092)-- (4.695965427257024,-8.282540437720282)-- (4.695965427257024,-8.222132017527201)-- (4.695965427257024,-8.16172359733412)-- (4.695965427257024,-8.101315177141041)-- (4.695965427257024,-8.04090675694796)-- (4.695965427257024,-7.980498336754881)-- (4.695965427257024,-7.9049878115135295)-- (4.695965427257024,-7.82947728627218)-- (4.695965427257024,-7.7690688660791)-- (4.695965427257024,-7.708660445886019)-- (4.695965427257024,-7.64825202569294)-- (4.695965427257024,-7.587843605499858)-- (4.711067532305294,-7.542537290355049)-- (4.711067532305294,-7.482128870161968)-- (4.726169637353564,-7.436822555017157)-- (4.726169637353564,-7.376414134824078)-- (4.756373847450104,-7.331107819679268)-- (4.771475952498374,-7.270699399486187)-- (4.771475952498374,-7.195188874244837)-- (4.801680162594915,-7.119678349003487)-- (4.831884372691455,-7.059269928810406)-- (4.862088582787995,-6.983759403569056)-- (4.862088582787995,-6.908248878327706)-- (4.9073948979328055,-6.847840458134625)-- (4.937599108029346,-6.787432037941545)-- (4.952701213077615,-6.742125722796735)-- (4.967803318125886,-6.696819407651924)-- (5.013109633270696,-6.636410987458844)-- (5.028211738318967,-6.591104672314035)-- (5.058415948415506,-6.545798357169224)-- (5.088620158512047,-6.5004920420244146)-- (5.1339264736568575,-6.455185726879604)-- (5.164130683753397,-6.3796752016382525)-- (5.179232788801667,-6.3343688864934435)-- (5.224539103946477,-6.289062571348634)-- (5.254743314043019,-6.213552046107282)-- (5.284947524139559,-6.153143625914202)-- (5.345355944332638,-6.062530995624582)-- (5.3604580493809095,-6.017224680479773)-- (5.405764364525719,-5.956816260286691)-- (5.420866469573989,-5.911509945141882)-- (5.4661727847188,-5.866203629997072)-- (5.51147909986361,-5.790693104755721)-- (5.54168330996015,-5.7302846845626405)-- (5.602091730153231,-5.65477415932129)-- (5.6322959402497705,-5.60946784417648)-- (5.677602255394581,-5.57926363407994)-- (5.722908570539392,-5.5490594239834)-- (5.768214885684202,-5.5188552138868605)-- (5.813521200829013,-5.48865100379032)-- (5.843725410925552,-5.44334468864551)-- (5.889031726070363,-5.41314047854897)-- (5.919235936166904,-5.367834163404159)-- (5.9645422513117134,-5.352732058355889)-- (6.024950671504794,-5.292323638162809)-- (6.070256986649605,-5.277221533114539)-- (6.115563301794414,-5.231915217969729)-- (6.160869616939225,-5.1866089028249185)-- (6.221278037132305,-5.141302587680109)-- (6.281686457325387,-5.095996272535298)-- (6.342094877518466,-5.050689957390487)-- (6.372299087615006,-5.005383642245677)-- (6.417605402759817,-4.960077327100868);
\draw [line width=2.pt,color=qqqqff] (4.,-4.)-- (4.,-8.);
\draw [line width=2.pt,color=qqqqff] (4.,-8.)-- (8.,-8.);
\draw [line width=2.pt,color=qqqqff] (8.,-8.)-- (8.,-12.);
\draw [line width=2.pt,color=qqqqff] (8.,-12.)-- (0.,-12.);
\draw [line width=2.pt,color=ttzzqq] (4.,-4.)-- (6.803147029375748,-4.);
\draw [line width=2.pt,color=ttzzqq] (0.,-9.495604623460858)-- (0.,-12.);
\draw [line width=2.pt,color=ttzzqq] (0.,-9.495604623460858)-- (1.2979917913962629,-9.822955152643875);
\draw [line width=2.pt,color=ttzzqq] (6.417605402759644,-4.9600773271010405)-- (6.803147029375748,-4.);
\draw [color=ttzzqq](5.,-2.9061910405361395) node[anchor=north west] {$Q'(\partial S)$};
\draw [color=qqqqff](2.,-6.742125722796737) node[anchor=north west] {$P(S)$};
\draw [color=ffqqqq](5.919235936166903,-9.082952005278598) node[anchor=north west] {$S$};
\draw [color=zzttqq] (6.803147029375748,-4.)-- (4.,-4.);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (4.,-4.)-- (4.,-8.);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (4.,-8.)-- (4.695965427257001,-8.);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (4.695965427257001,-8.)-- (4.80470058360462,-7.113637506984076);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (4.80470058360462,-7.113637506984076)-- (5.168661315267897,-6.366083307094751);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (5.168661315267897,-6.366083307094751)-- (5.62316470182041,-5.62316470182041);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (5.62316470182041,-5.62316470182041)-- (6.417605402759644,-4.9600773271010405);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (6.417605402759644,-4.9600773271010405)-- (6.803147029375748,-4.);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (4.695965427257001,-8.)-- (8.,-8.);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (8.,-8.)-- (8.,-12.);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (8.,-12.)-- (0.,-12.);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (0.,-12.)-- (0.,-9.495604623460858);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (0.,-9.495604623460858)-- (1.2979917913962629,-9.822955152643875);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (1.2979917913962629,-9.822955152643875)-- (1.314604106949337,-10.23524262046158);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (1.314604106949337,-10.23524262046158)-- (1.487136471890958,-10.512863528109042);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (1.487136471890958,-10.512863528109042)-- (2.6686730353468873,-10.668673035346888);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (2.6686730353468873,-10.668673035346888)-- (4.,-10.80459198078136);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (4.,-10.80459198078136)-- (5.195408019218509,-10.804591980781492);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (5.195408019218509,-10.804591980781492)-- (5.941308243544778,-10.709332548938692);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (5.941308243544778,-10.709332548938692)-- (6.519352430834264,-10.519352430834264);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (6.519352430834264,-10.519352430834264)-- (7.275110294280937,-10.170671912779817);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (7.275110294280937,-10.170671912779817)-- (7.716386436911047,-9.626627787016314);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (7.716386436911047,-9.626627787016314)-- (7.523544172448507,-9.402419612068915);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (7.523544172448507,-9.402419612068915)-- (6.84046434411138,-9.098054110326865);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (6.84046434411138,-9.098054110326865)-- (5.514499520873422,-8.681236010994665);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (5.514499520873422,-8.681236010994665)-- (4.726169637353564,-8.373153068009902);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (4.726169637353564,-8.373153068009902)-- (4.695965427257001,-8.);
\draw [color=zzttqq](4.,-4.416401545363146) node[anchor=north west] {$Q(S)$};
\draw (0.,-10.034384623319612)-- (1.3056064941294359,-10.011938229567473);
\draw (0.,-10.532754089912524)-- (1.3125044532088443,-10.183133032174819);
\draw (0.,-10.985817241360627)-- (1.3634122722797144,-10.31377957881262);
\draw (0.,-11.529493023098349)-- (1.436310437119546,-10.431079626809506);
\draw (0.,-12.)-- (1.4871364718909592,-10.51286352810904);
\draw (0.5428865389827409,-12.)-- (1.6079927629378525,-10.538060003630019);
\draw (1.0563581106239248,-12.)-- (1.7272589935990967,-10.578060405057338);
\draw (1.5547275772168387,-11.96745406949818)-- (1.8657559980314014,-10.593162510105554);
\draw (1.9775865185684018,-12.)-- (1.9931833361713749,-10.608264615153876);
\draw (2.400445459919965,-12.)-- (2.119380335300796,-10.596237676534804);
\draw (2.8535086113680688,-12.)-- (2.262501298421209,-10.615111071932718);
\draw (3.291469657767902,-11.98255617454645)-- (2.4272746876936457,-10.655916354843765);
\draw (3.669022283974655,-11.98255617454645)-- (2.5497191623296946,-10.652986559860567);
\draw (4.,-12.)-- (2.6686730353468633,-10.668673035346897);
\draw (4.,-11.605003548339699)-- (2.8572225111463605,-10.687922586053288);
\draw (4.,-11.136838291843326)-- (3.229510389398094,-10.698877245443475);
\end{tikzpicture}
\end{center}

\end{minipage}

\end{frame}

\begin{frame}

\frametitle{Proof of a weak form of the relative Euclidean filling inequality}


\begin{minipage}{6cm}

$V$ = cube of side $R$. Clip $S$ by smaller cube $\mu V$, $\mu<1$, creating $S'=S\llcorner 1_{\mu V}$ such that $M(\partial S') < \frac{C}{R}\,M(S)$.

\bigskip

Apply the Deformation Theorem with parameter $\eps=R$. The grid can be chosen not to intersect $\mu V$. Then $P(S')$ and $Q(\partial S')$ have support outside $\mu V$. Let $T=Q(S')$ and $\tilde S=-P(S')-Q'(\partial S')$. Then 
$$\partial T=S+\tilde S\quad \text{outside}\quad \mu V,$$ 
and
$$
M(T) < C\,R\,M(S),\quad M(\tilde S) < C\,M(S),\quad M(\partial\tilde S) < \frac{C}{R}\,M(S).
$$

\end{minipage}\hskip.5cm\begin{minipage}{4cm}

\begin{center}
\definecolor{ffxfqq}{rgb}{1.,0.4980392156862745,0.}
\definecolor{zzttqq}{rgb}{0.6,0.2,0.}
\definecolor{qqffqq}{rgb}{0.,1.,0.}
\definecolor{ffqqqq}{rgb}{1.,0.,0.}
\begin{tikzpicture}[line cap=round,line join=round,>=triangle 45,x=0.4cm,y=0.4cm]
\clip(-0.13842991978215666,-12.437563282466146) rectangle (9.482136807663995,-3.);
\fill[color=zzttqq,fill=zzttqq,fill opacity=0.1] (0.9868418470740412,-9.274637235086553) -- (0.,-9.714920520704219) -- (0.,-12.) -- (8.,-12.) -- (8.,-4.) -- (6.11548588366728,-4.) -- (5.514286631560278,-4.988466937547838) -- (5.20017750634222,-5.492538780996089) -- (4.778298070535423,-5.8988219345179775) -- (4.442744057175576,-6.068119578720676) -- (3.906465890809005,-6.020472936340268) -- (3.582063219282899,-6.14212393816256) -- (3.052881361355946,-6.249582323105578) -- (2.853716836577648,-6.383086499464404) -- (2.781194123952819,-6.841617198640735) -- (2.8194050155508465,-7.235423326334696) -- (2.963670626686255,-7.581660793059678) -- (3.2373853807864093,-7.733724545337542) -- (3.7138518045903792,-7.784412462763496) -- (4.165364176738481,-7.933356958584367) -- (4.294675705447788,-8.191704787492048) -- (4.332244397187024,-8.524456057182437) -- (4.095024943633582,-9.130683549596805) -- (3.8330697863762317,-9.443732127619548) -- (3.6570813370732447,-9.530104338913402) -- (3.050229993367523,-9.524957565759374) -- (2.674749497358356,-8.945165771817901) -- (1.9344077387192284,-8.373584961785182) -- (1.5303722847031078,-8.71629032928682) -- cycle;
\draw (0.,-12.)-- (8.,-12.);
\draw (8.,-12.)-- (8.,-4.);
\draw (8.,-4.)-- (0.,-4.);
\draw (0.,-4.)-- (0.,-12.);
\draw [line width=1.6pt] (1.,-11.)-- (7.,-11.);
\draw [line width=1.6pt] (7.,-11.)-- (7.,-5.);
\draw [line width=1.6pt] (7.,-5.)-- (1.,-5.);
\draw [line width=1.6pt] (1.,-5.)-- (1.,-11.);
\draw [line width=4.4pt,color=ffqqqq] (0.9868418470740316,-9.274637235086567)-- (1.0071170140444134,-9.244224484630996)-- (1.0375297644999861,-9.213811734175419)-- (1.0780800984407497,-9.173261400234658)-- (1.1084928488963224,-9.142848649779083)-- (1.149043182837086,-9.092160732353129)-- (1.1693183498074675,-9.06174798189756)-- (1.1997311002630404,-9.031335231441982)-- (1.2504190176889947,-8.980647314016029)-- (1.2706941846593767,-8.950234563560455)-- (1.321382102085331,-8.899546646134501)-- (1.3619324360260947,-8.858996312193737)-- (1.3923451864816672,-8.838721145223355)-- (1.4227579369372398,-8.808308394767783)-- (1.4633082708780034,-8.77789564431221)-- (1.493721021333576,-8.757620477341828)-- (1.5139961883039579,-8.727207726886254)-- (1.5444089387595306,-8.706932559915874)-- (1.5849592727002941,-8.66638222597511)-- (1.625509606641058,-8.625831892034347)-- (1.6559223570966302,-8.595419141578773)-- (1.686335107552203,-8.565006391123198)-- (1.7268854414929664,-8.524456057182437)-- (1.76743577543373,-8.494043306726862)-- (1.8079861093744936,-8.463630556271289)-- (1.838398859830066,-8.433217805815717)-- (1.8688116102856387,-8.402805055360146)-- (1.8992243607412116,-8.38252988838976)-- (1.9296371111967843,-8.372392304904572)-- (1.970187445137548,-8.38252988838976)-- (2.0006001955931203,-8.402805055360146)-- (2.041150529533884,-8.423080222330526)-- (2.0715632799894563,-8.4534929727861)-- (2.1019760304450292,-8.473768139756482)-- (2.132388780900602,-8.504180890212055)-- (2.1628015313561746,-8.514318473697246)-- (2.1932142818117475,-8.544731224152818)-- (2.2439021992377017,-8.585281558093582)-- (2.274314949693274,-8.615694308549156)-- (2.304727700148847,-8.646107059004727)-- (2.3351404506044195,-8.66638222597511)-- (2.3554156175748013,-8.696794976430683)-- (2.395965951515565,-8.727207726886254)-- (2.4263787019711374,-8.757620477341828)-- (2.4567914524267107,-8.788033227797401)-- (2.487204202882283,-8.808308394767783)-- (2.5277545368230467,-8.848858728708546)-- (2.558167287278619,-8.869133895678928)-- (2.598717621219383,-8.90968422961969)-- (2.6291303716749557,-8.919821813104882)-- (2.659543122130528,-8.929959396590073)-- (2.689955872586101,-8.960372147045646)-- (2.7102310395564824,-8.99078489750122)-- (2.750781373497246,-9.041472814927173)-- (2.771056540467628,-9.071885565382747)-- (2.8014692909232,-9.11243589932351)-- (2.8217444578935824,-9.152986233264274)-- (2.842019624863964,-9.183398983719847)-- (2.8724323753195367,-9.22394931766061)-- (2.8927075422899184,-9.264499651601376)-- (2.9129827092603007,-9.30504998554214)-- (2.9332578762306825,-9.335462735997714)-- (2.9433954597158727,-9.365875486453286)-- (2.963670626686255,-9.396288236908859)-- (2.973808210171446,-9.426700987364432)-- (2.9839457936566367,-9.457113737820004)-- (2.9940833771418274,-9.487526488275577)-- (3.0244961275974003,-9.50780165524596)-- (3.054908878052973,-9.528076822216342)-- (3.085321628508545,-9.548351989186722)-- (3.125871962449309,-9.548351989186722)-- (3.1664222963900728,-9.548351989186722)-- (3.2069726303308363,-9.558489572671913)-- (3.2475229642715995,-9.558489572671913)-- (3.2779357147271724,-9.548351989186722)-- (3.3286236321531266,-9.548351989186722)-- (3.36917396609389,-9.548351989186722)-- (3.3995867165494627,-9.538214405701533)-- (3.4401370504902267,-9.538214405701533)-- (3.470549800945799,-9.548351989186722)-- (3.500962551401372,-9.538214405701533)-- (3.5313753018569445,-9.548351989186722)-- (3.59220080276809,-9.538214405701533)-- (3.632751136708853,-9.538214405701533)-- (3.663163887164426,-9.528076822216342)-- (3.7037142211051894,-9.51793923873115)-- (3.7341269715607623,-9.497664071760768)-- (3.774677305501526,-9.477388904790386)-- (3.815227639442289,-9.457113737820004)-- (3.8557779733830526,-9.426700987364432)-- (3.8861907238386255,-9.396288236908859)-- (3.916603474294198,-9.376013069938477)-- (3.947016224749771,-9.345600319482905)-- (3.9672913917201527,-9.315187569027332)-- (3.9977041421757247,-9.29491240205695)-- (4.017979309146107,-9.264499651601376)-- (4.03825447611649,-9.234086901145805)-- (4.058529643086871,-9.203674150690231)-- (4.078804810057252,-9.173261400234658)-- (4.088942393542443,-9.142848649779083)-- (4.109217560512825,-9.102298315838322)-- (4.129492727483207,-9.071885565382747)-- (4.139630310968397,-9.031335231441982)-- (4.159905477938779,-9.000922480986409)-- (4.180180644909161,-8.950234563560455)-- (4.190318228394352,-8.90968422961969)-- (4.210593395364733,-8.869133895678928)-- (4.230868562335115,-8.818445978252972)-- (4.2410061458203065,-8.788033227797401)-- (4.261281312790688,-8.757620477341828)-- (4.271418896275879,-8.706932559915874)-- (4.291694063246261,-8.66638222597511)-- (4.3018316467314515,-8.635969475519536)-- (4.322106813701834,-8.595419141578773)-- (4.332244397187024,-8.565006391123198)-- (4.332244397187024,-8.524456057182437)-- (4.332244397187024,-8.483905723241673)-- (4.332244397187024,-8.443355389300908)-- (4.332244397187024,-8.402805055360146)-- (4.322106813701834,-8.372392304904572)-- (4.322106813701834,-8.331841970963808)-- (4.311969230216643,-8.291291637023043)-- (4.311969230216643,-8.250741303082279)-- (4.3018316467314515,-8.220328552626707)-- (4.291694063246261,-8.179778218685941)-- (4.271418896275879,-8.14936546823037)-- (4.261281312790688,-8.118952717774796)-- (4.2410061458203065,-8.088539967319225)-- (4.230868562335115,-8.058127216863651)-- (4.210593395364733,-8.027714466408078)-- (4.200455811879542,-7.9973017159525055)-- (4.190318228394352,-7.966888965496933)-- (4.1700430614239705,-7.93647621504136)-- (4.139630310968397,-7.916201048070978)-- (4.088942393542443,-7.885788297615405)-- (4.058529643086871,-7.875650714130214)-- (4.028116892631298,-7.865513130645024)-- (3.9977041421757247,-7.8553755471598325)-- (3.9672913917201527,-7.83510038018945)-- (3.9368786412645798,-7.82496279670426)-- (3.9064658908090073,-7.814825213219069)-- (3.8760531403534353,-7.804687629733878)-- (3.8253652229274806,-7.804687629733878)-- (3.784814888986716,-7.794550046248687)-- (3.7341269715607623,-7.784412462763496)-- (3.6935766376199988,-7.784412462763496)-- (3.6226135532236627,-7.774274879278305)-- (3.59220080276809,-7.764137295793114)-- (3.5516504688273263,-7.764137295793114)-- (3.521237718371754,-7.753999712307923)-- (3.460412217460608,-7.753999712307923)-- (3.3995867165494627,-7.753999712307923)-- (3.36917396609389,-7.743862128822732)-- (3.3184860486679355,-7.733724545337542)-- (3.2677981312419817,-7.733724545337542)-- (3.217110213816027,-7.733724545337542)-- (3.1866974633604546,-7.71344937836716)-- (3.1562847129048817,-7.7033117948819685)-- (3.125871962449309,-7.693174211396777)-- (3.0954592119937363,-7.672899044426396)-- (3.065046461538164,-7.662761460941205)-- (3.034633711082591,-7.652623877456014)-- (3.014358544112209,-7.622211127000441)-- (2.9839457936566367,-7.601935960030058)-- (2.953533043201064,-7.571523209574487)-- (2.9332578762306825,-7.541110459118914)-- (2.9129827092603007,-7.51069770866334)-- (2.8927075422899184,-7.4701473747225755)-- (2.8825699588047278,-7.439734624267003)-- (2.862294791834346,-7.409321873811431)-- (2.862294791834346,-7.368771539870665)-- (2.842019624863964,-7.328221205929902)-- (2.8318820413787735,-7.287670871989139)-- (2.8217444578935824,-7.2471205380483745)-- (2.8116068744083917,-7.19643262062242)-- (2.8014692909232,-7.155882286681656)-- (2.79133170743801,-7.115331952740892)-- (2.79133170743801,-7.074781618800129)-- (2.781194123952819,-7.0240937013741735)-- (2.781194123952819,-6.98354336743341)-- (2.781194123952819,-6.932855450007454)-- (2.781194123952819,-6.8720299490963095)-- (2.781194123952819,-6.821342031670355)-- (2.781194123952819,-6.7706541142444)-- (2.781194123952819,-6.7199661968184445)-- (2.781194123952819,-6.679415862877681)-- (2.781194123952819,-6.638865528936918)-- (2.781194123952819,-6.588177611510964)-- (2.79133170743801,-6.547627277570199)-- (2.8014692909232,-6.517214527114625)-- (2.8116068744083917,-6.476664193173862)-- (2.8217444578935824,-6.446251442718289)-- (2.8318820413787735,-6.4158386922627155)-- (2.852157208349155,-6.385425941807143)-- (2.8724323753195367,-6.355013191351571)-- (2.8927075422899184,-6.324600440895997)-- (2.9231202927454913,-6.314462857410807)-- (2.953533043201064,-6.294187690440425)-- (2.9839457936566367,-6.2739125234700435)-- (3.014358544112209,-6.263774939984852)-- (3.044771294567782,-6.25363735649966)-- (3.085321628508545,-6.233362189529278)-- (3.125871962449309,-6.223224606044089)-- (3.1562847129048817,-6.213087022558897)-- (3.1866974633604546,-6.202949439073706)-- (3.217110213816027,-6.1928118555885145)-- (3.2475229642715995,-6.182674272103324)-- (3.2880732982123635,-6.162399105132942)-- (3.3184860486679355,-6.152261521647751)-- (3.348898799123509,-6.14212393816256)-- (3.389449133064272,-6.14212393816256)-- (3.429999467005036,-6.14212393816256)-- (3.470549800945799,-6.14212393816256)-- (3.5111001348865627,-6.14212393816256)-- (3.5516504688273263,-6.14212393816256)-- (3.59220080276809,-6.14212393816256)-- (3.6226135532236627,-6.1218487711921785)-- (3.6530263036792348,-6.111711187706987)-- (3.6834390541348077,-6.101573604221796)-- (3.7341269715607623,-6.081298437251415)-- (3.774677305501526,-6.071160853766224)-- (3.805090055957099,-6.061023270281033)-- (3.835502806412671,-6.040748103310651)-- (3.8659155568682433,-6.030610519825459)-- (3.896328307323816,-6.020472936340268)-- (3.947016224749771,-6.020472936340268)-- (3.9875665586905344,-6.020472936340268)-- (4.017979309146107,-6.030610519825459)-- (4.058529643086871,-6.030610519825459)-- (4.099079977027634,-6.030610519825459)-- (4.129492727483207,-6.040748103310651)-- (4.159905477938779,-6.050885686795841)-- (4.200455811879542,-6.061023270281033)-- (4.2410061458203065,-6.061023270281033)-- (4.281556479761069,-6.061023270281033)-- (4.322106813701834,-6.061023270281033)-- (4.362657147642597,-6.061023270281033)-- (4.403207481583361,-6.061023270281033)-- (4.433620232038933,-6.071160853766224)-- (4.464032982494506,-6.061023270281033)-- (4.494445732950078,-6.040748103310651)-- (4.534996066890842,-6.020472936340268)-- (4.565408817346414,-6.010335352855078)-- (4.595821567801988,-6.000197769369887)-- (4.62623431825756,-5.979922602399505)-- (4.6566470687131325,-5.9596474354291225)-- (4.687059819168706,-5.949509851943932)-- (4.717472569624277,-5.92923468497355)-- (4.747885320079851,-5.908959518003169)-- (4.778298070535423,-5.8988219345179775)-- (4.808710820990996,-5.878546767547595)-- (4.839123571446569,-5.848134017092023)-- (4.8695363219021415,-5.8177212666364495)-- (4.910086655842904,-5.797446099666067)-- (4.930361822813286,-5.767033349210495)-- (4.960774573268859,-5.746758182240113)-- (4.991187323724432,-5.726483015269731)-- (5.0114624906948135,-5.696070264814158)-- (5.041875241150386,-5.6656575143585854)-- (5.052012824635577,-5.635244763903012)-- (5.0824255750911504,-5.604832013447439)-- (5.112838325546723,-5.584556846477057)-- (5.133113492517104,-5.554144096021484)-- (5.163526242972677,-5.533868929051103)-- (5.183801409943058,-5.503456178595529)-- (5.214214160398631,-5.483181011625148)-- (5.234489327369013,-5.452768261169576)-- (5.264902077824586,-5.432493094199193)-- (5.285177244794967,-5.39194276025843)-- (5.30545241176535,-5.351392426317665)-- (5.32572757873573,-5.320979675862092)-- (5.356140329191304,-5.300704508891711)-- (5.3662779126764955,-5.270291758436138)-- (5.376415496161685,-5.239879007980565)-- (5.386553079646877,-5.209466257524992)-- (5.416965830102449,-5.18919109055461)-- (5.4271034135876395,-5.158778340099038)-- (5.447378580558022,-5.128365589643465)-- (5.467653747528403,-5.097952839187891)-- (5.487928914498785,-5.057402505247127)-- (5.5082040814691675,-5.006714587821172)-- (5.518341664954358,-4.976301837365599);
\draw [line width=2.pt,color=qqffqq] (5.514286631560278,-4.988466937547838)-- (6.11548588366728,-4.);
\draw [line width=2.pt,color=qqffqq] (0.9868418470740412,-9.274637235086553)-- (0.,-9.714920520704219);
\draw [line width=2.pt,color=qqffqq] (6.11548588366728,-4.)-- (0.,-4.);
\draw [line width=2.pt,color=qqffqq] (0.,-4.)-- (0.,-5.256319224429117);
\draw [line width=2.pt,color=qqffqq] (0.,-4.)-- (8.,-4.);
\draw [line width=2.pt,color=qqffqq] (8.,-4.)-- (8.,-12.);
\draw [line width=2.pt,color=qqffqq] (8.,-12.)-- (0.,-12.);
\draw [line width=2.pt,color=qqffqq] (0.,-12.)-- (0.,-8.688583890626482);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (0.9868418470740412,-9.274637235086553)-- (0.,-9.714920520704219);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (0.,-9.714920520704219)-- (0.,-12.);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (0.,-12.)-- (8.,-12.);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (8.,-12.)-- (8.,-4.);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (8.,-4.)-- (6.11548588366728,-4.);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (6.11548588366728,-4.)-- (5.514286631560278,-4.988466937547838);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (5.514286631560278,-4.988466937547838)-- (5.20017750634222,-5.492538780996089);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (5.20017750634222,-5.492538780996089)-- (4.778298070535423,-5.8988219345179775);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (4.778298070535423,-5.8988219345179775)-- (4.442744057175576,-6.068119578720676);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (4.442744057175576,-6.068119578720676)-- (3.906465890809005,-6.020472936340268);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (3.906465890809005,-6.020472936340268)-- (3.582063219282899,-6.14212393816256);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (3.582063219282899,-6.14212393816256)-- (3.052881361355946,-6.249582323105578);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (3.052881361355946,-6.249582323105578)-- (2.853716836577648,-6.383086499464404);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (2.853716836577648,-6.383086499464404)-- (2.781194123952819,-6.841617198640735);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (2.781194123952819,-6.841617198640735)-- (2.8194050155508465,-7.235423326334696);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (2.8194050155508465,-7.235423326334696)-- (2.963670626686255,-7.581660793059678);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (2.963670626686255,-7.581660793059678)-- (3.2373853807864093,-7.733724545337542);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (3.2373853807864093,-7.733724545337542)-- (3.7138518045903792,-7.784412462763496);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (3.7138518045903792,-7.784412462763496)-- (4.165364176738481,-7.933356958584367);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (4.165364176738481,-7.933356958584367)-- (4.294675705447788,-8.191704787492048);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (4.294675705447788,-8.191704787492048)-- (4.332244397187024,-8.524456057182437);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (4.332244397187024,-8.524456057182437)-- (4.095024943633582,-9.130683549596805);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (4.095024943633582,-9.130683549596805)-- (3.8330697863762317,-9.443732127619548);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (3.8330697863762317,-9.443732127619548)-- (3.6570813370732447,-9.530104338913402);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (3.6570813370732447,-9.530104338913402)-- (3.050229993367523,-9.524957565759374);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (3.050229993367523,-9.524957565759374)-- (2.674749497358356,-8.945165771817901);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (2.674749497358356,-8.945165771817901)-- (1.9344077387192284,-8.373584961785182);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (1.9344077387192284,-8.373584961785182)-- (1.5303722847031078,-8.71629032928682);
\draw [color=zzttqq] (1.5303722847031078,-8.71629032928682)-- (0.9868418470740412,-9.274637235086553);
\draw [color=zzttqq](4.342381980672215,-6.6388655289369165) node[anchor=north west] {$Q(S')$};
\draw [color=qqffqq](8.214938872015134,-7.41945945729662) node[anchor=north west] {$\tilde S$};
\draw (1.,-5.604832013447439) node[anchor=north west] {$\mu V$};
\draw (-0.2,-5.61496959693263) node[anchor=north west] {$V$};
\draw [color=ffqqqq](3.0346337110825905,-4.9053387529692625) node[anchor=north west] {$S'$};
\draw [shift={(1.560339427093426,-10.220328951633666)},line width=4.4pt,color=ffxfqq]  plot[domain=2.115931713955814:3.2399583752221597,variable=\t]({1.*1.1059983259634332*cos(\t r)+0.*1.1059983259634332*sin(\t r)},{0.*1.1059983259634332*cos(\t r)+1.*1.1059983259634332*sin(\t r)});
\draw [color=ffxfqq](0.14542241780318815,-10.531697587250244) node[anchor=north west] {$S$};
\end{tikzpicture}
\end{center}

\bigskip

\end{minipage}

\end{frame}

\begin{frame}

\frametitle{Proof of the Heisenberg relative filling inequality}

In Heisenberg group, no triangulation whose simplices (up to dimension $m$) are horizontal. Nonhorizontal triangulations behave badly under inflation.

\medskip

R. Young fixes an arbitrary periodic triangulation and uses a map $\phi:\tau\to \H^{2m+1}$ which is horizontal on simplices of dimensions $\le m$, and moves points a bounded distance away. He uses a Riemannian Deformation Theorem, followed by pushing with $\phi$, to improve deflates $\delta_{2^{-i}}(S)$, and inflates them, getting chains $P_i$. Then he fills differences $P_{i+1}-P_i$.


\begin{center}
\includegraphics[width=3in]{Young_picture.png}\tiny{R. Young}
\end{center}\pause

We reproduce R. Young's arguments, getting $T$ such that $\partial T=S+\tilde S$ where $\tilde S$ merely avoids a smallish cube $\eps V$. To push $\tilde S$ outside the large cube $\mu V$, we use a \emph{stretch contact transformation} mapping $V$ to $V$ and $\eps V$ to $\mu V$.

\end{frame}

\begin{frame}

\frametitle{Balogh-F\"assler-Platis' stretch map}

\emph{We reproduce R. Young's arguments, getting $T$ such that $\partial T=S+\tilde S$ where $\tilde S$ merely avoids a smallish cube $\eps V$. To push $\tilde S$ outside the large cube $\mu V$, we use a \emph{stretch contact transformation} mapping $V$ to $V$ and $\eps V$ to $\mu V$.}

\begin{proposition}[\ncite{Z. Balogh, K. F\"assler and I. Platis (2013) if $m=1$}]
Assume that balls are $U(m)$-invariant. There exists a one-parameter group of global contact transformations $f_t$ of $\H^{2m+1}\setminus\{e\}$ which maps the ball of radius $R$ onto the ball of radius $R^{\exp(t)}$.
\end{proposition}

This group, generated by the Hamiltonian given in exponential coordinates by $H(z,t)=2t\log(|z|)$, is a combination of commuting dilations and rotations.


\begin{center}
\definecolor{ffqqqq}{rgb}{1.,0.,0.}
\definecolor{qqqqff}{rgb}{0.,0.,1.}
\begin{tikzpicture}[line cap=round,line join=round,>=triangle 45,x=0.4cm,y=0.4cm]
\clip(1.5107322103036864,-3.4933384140351293) rectangle (16.622521445063036,3.820552461150959);
\draw [line width=2.pt] (5.,0.) circle (1.2cm);
\draw [line width=2.pt] (13.,0.) circle (1.2cm);
\draw [line width=1.2pt] (5.,0.) circle (0.16499079967718164cm);
\draw [line width=1.2pt] (13.,0.) circle (1.0955084262556132cm);
\draw [shift={(8.796851306553963,0.06285215310234368)}] plot[domain=0.771570401815238:2.3003524990358604,variable=\t]({1.*3.34974745143424*cos(\t r)+0.*3.34974745143424*sin(\t r)},{0.*3.34974745143424*cos(\t r)+1.*3.34974745143424*sin(\t r)});
\draw [shift={(8.698687279536214,-3.913275424249045)}] plot[domain=1.22722418643692:2.2516819143823703,variable=\t]({1.*5.32966228511102*cos(\t r)+0.*5.32966228511102*sin(\t r)},{0.*5.32966228511102*cos(\t r)+1.*5.32966228511102*sin(\t r)});
\draw (8.897038444455555,1.4126946177911819)-- (8.657016818915093,1.6047119182235499);
\draw (8.897038444455555,1.4126946177911819)-- (8.609012493807,1.236678759061511);
\draw (9.121058628293321,3.396873388925653)-- (8.897038444455555,3.556887805952626);
\draw (9.121058628293321,3.396873388925653)-- (8.897038444455555,3.268861855304074);
\draw [color=ffqqqq] (5.,0.) circle (0.10252571004263195cm);
\draw [color=ffqqqq] (13.,0.) circle (0.6649469776064243cm);
\draw [color=qqqqff] (5.,0.) circle (0.6785086887986229cm);
\draw [color=qqqqff] (13.,0.) circle (1.142131023121691cm);
\draw [color=qqqqff] (5.,0.) circle (0.9925932545884326cm);
\draw [color=qqqqff] (13.,0.) circle (1.176398847581147cm);
\draw [color=ffqqqq] (5.,0.) circle (0.06244342694728459cm);
\draw [color=ffqqqq] (13.,0.) circle (0.8653014051931909cm);
\begin{scriptsize}
\draw [fill=ffqqqq] (5.,0.) circle (1.pt);
\draw [fill=ffqqqq] (13.,0.) circle (2.5pt);
\end{scriptsize}
\end{tikzpicture}
\end{center}


\end{frame}

\begin{frame}

\frametitle{Alternative definitions of horizontal integral currents}


\textbf{Metric integral currents}. \ncite{L. Ambrosio and B. Kirchheim (2000)} define metric integral currents in general metric spaces.\pause

\medskip

\textbf{Integral Rumin currents}. \ncite{B. Franchi, R. Serapioni and F. Serra-Cassano (2007)} define Rumin currents (and mass, boundary,...) in $\H^{2m+1}$ by duality with Rumin differential forms. Integral Rumin currents, in dimensions $k\le m$, are defined as sums of currents of integration along horizontal Lip submanifolds. 
\pause

\begin{proposition}
In Heisenberg groups, horizontal integral currents, metric integral currents and integral Rumin currents coincide.
\end{proposition}\pause

\textbf{Ingredients}
\begin{enumerate}
  \item Ambrosio and Kirchheim's parametric representation of metric integral currents as sums of $f_{\#}T$, $T$ top dimensional integral current in $\R^k$, $f$ Lipschitz.
  \item Carnot-differentiability of Lipschitz maps $f:\R^k\to \H^{2m+1}$ implies $f^*\theta=0$ and $f^*d\theta=0$.
\end{enumerate}

\end{frame}


\begin{frame}

\frametitle{Summary}

\begin{itemize}
  \item Filling integral currents in groups and manifolds is useful.
  \item Filling in Carnot groups is widely open.
  \item In Heisenberg group, there is an easy notion of integral current in low dimensions, with several basic results (absolute and relative filling, compactness). There are still issues with rectifiability (Lusin property).
  \item Heisenberg integral currents of low codimension are nebulous.
\end{itemize}

\pause

\vskip1cm

\begin{center}
Thank you!
\end{center}

\end{frame}

\end{document}





